Seminar  |  11/05/2026 | 03:00 PM  –  04:15 PM

Net Zero Lab x I&E Seminar: Efficient Accounting for Scope 2 Emissions

Gunter Glenk (Mannheim University)


hybrid (Room 342/Zoom)

Companies across industries assess the (Scope 2) emissions embodied in the electricity they consume by counting renewable energy certificates procured against electricity drawn from the grid. Critics argue that such market-based accounting understates actual emissions by double-counting renewable energy and advocate location-based accounting, which assigns emissions at the average carbon intensity of the local grid. Modeling a competitive electricity market, this paper shows that either accounting method, when applied by all electricity buyers, captures the actual emissions generated. Yet only market-based methods can induce efficient investment in renewable energy, as certificate prices transmit the buyers' willingness to pay for lower emissions to suppliers. Location-based methods suppress this signal and lead to underinvestment. When buyers can choose between the two methods, as they can today, both are used in equilibrium, renewable energy is double counted, and investment is below the efficient level. Standard-setters, now revising their guidance, can prevent this outcome by requiring all buyers to assess any electricity not matched with certificates at the carbon intensity of the local generation left unclaimed, effectively implementing one method.


Contact person: Isabel Haase


Subscription to the invitation mailing list and more information on the seminar page.